Unknown mosaicist, Plato's Academy, Pompeii, 1st c. BC · Museo Archeologico Nazionale, Naples · public domain
17a
The Apology of Socrates 17a · I almost forgot who I was17aI almost forgot who I was
The trial of Socrates, Athens, 399 BC. His three accusers have spoken. Now the seventy-year-old defendant stands up to answer, and his first move is to praise their eloquence.
· · ·
ὅτι1
hóti
howwhat
μὲν3
mèn
indeedon the one hand
ὑμεῖς2
hymeîs
you
, ὦ4
ô
O
ἄνδρες5
ándres
men
Ἀθηναῖοι6
Athēnaîoi
of AthensAthenians
, πεπόνθατε7
pepónthate
have been affectedhave suffered
ὑπὸ8
hypò
by
τῶν9
tôn
the
ἐμῶν10
emôn
my
κατηγόρων11
katēgórōn
accusersspeakers-against
, οὐκ12
ouk
not
οἶδα13
oîda
I do know
·; ἐγὼ14
egṑ
I
δʼ15
d’
but
οὖν16
oûn
at any rateso
καὶ17
kaì
even
αὐτὸς18
autòs
myselfself
ὑπʼ22
hyp’
because ofby
αὐτῶν23
autôn
them
ὀλίγου19
olígou
almostby a little
ἐμαυτοῦ20
emautoû
who I wasmyself
ἐπελαθόμην21
epelathómēn
forgot
, οὕτω24
hoútō
so
πιθανῶς25
pithanôs
persuasivelybelievably
ἔλεγον26
élegon
did they speak
. καίτοι27
kaítoi
And yet
ἀληθές29
alēthés
trueunhidden
γε30
ge
at allat least
ὡς32
hōs
soas
ἔπος33
épos
to speaka word
εἰπεῖν34
eipeîn
(to say)
οὐδὲν31
oudèn
nothingnot one thing
εἰρήκασιν28
eirḗkasin
they have said
. How you, for your part, men of Athens, have been affected by my accusers, I do not know. But I, at any rate, even myself almost forgot who I was because of them, so persuasively did they speak. And yet they have said nothing true at all, so to speak.
How you, for your part, men of Athens, have been affected by my accusers, I do not know. But I, at any rate, even myself almost forgot who I was because of them, so persuasively did they speak. And yet they have said nothing true at all, so to speak.
Interpretation
How you, men of Athens, have been affected by my accusers, I do not know. But I myself almost forgot who I was because of them, so persuasively did they speak. And yet, so to speak, they have said nothing true at all.
The first word of the speech is a small joke. Socrates was famous for saying he knew nothing, and the first thing he tells the jury is something he does not know: how they have taken the prosecution. Then he pays his accusers a compliment that is really a charge. They spoke so well that he nearly lost track of himself, and none of it was true. Pithanōs, "persuasively," is the word at the centre of the whole trial: Athens is about to decide whether a good speech or a true one wins.
The Greek for "true" is alēthes, from a-, "not," and the root of lanthanō, "escape notice." Truth is what is not hidden. The verb for "I forgot" in the line before, epelathomēn, comes from the same root. Socrates says the speeches made him forget himself, and that they hid the truth, with one root in both places.
17a2
The Apology of Socrates 17a2 · The lie that amazed him most17a2The lie that amazed him most
Of all their lies, one surprises him more than the rest: the warning that he is a dangerous speaker.
· · ·
And most of all, of the many things that they lied about, one thing of theirs I was amazed at: this, in which they said that you ought to be careful not to be deceived by me, since I am clever at speaking.