‹ LibraryEnchiridion · Chapter 5Read on ›
5.1
Enchiridion 5.1 · Not things, but opinions about them
The most quoted line in the Handbook, and the seed of a long afterlife (Montaigne, Shakespeare, modern cognitive therapy). What rattles people, Epictetus says, is never the event itself but the verdict they pass on it — and he points to Socrates as proof.
· · ·
 
It is
οὐ1
ou
not
τοὺς2
toùs
the
πράγματα3
prágmata
thingsthing, matter, fact, (pl.) circumstances
 
that
ταράσσει4
tarássei
disturbto stir up, trouble
τὰ5
tà
the
ἀνθρώπους6
anthrṓpous
peoplehuman being, person
,
ἀλλὰ7
allà
butyet
τὰ8
tà
the
δόγματα9
dógmata
opinionsopinion, judgment, belief
περὶ10
perì
aboutconcerning
τῶν11
tō͂n
the
πραγμάτων12
pragmátōn
thingsthing, matter, fact, (pl.) circumstances
.
οἷον13
ohi͂on
For examplesuch as, of what kind
ὁ14
ho
the
θάνατος15
thánatos
death
,
 
is
οὐδὲν16
oudèn
nothingno one, (neut.) nothing
δεινόν17
deinón
terriblefearful, (also) clever
ἐπεὶ18
epeì
sincebecause, when
καὶ19
kaì
alsoand, even
Σωκράτει20
Sōkrátei
to Socrates
ἂν21
àn
(modalpotential particle, with subj. = ἐάν, 'if')
ἐφαίνετο22
ephaíneto
would have seemed soto show, (mid. / pass.) appear, seem
ἀλλὰ23
allà
butyet
τὸ24
tò
the
δόγμα25
dógma
opinionjudgment, belief
περὶ26
perì
aboutconcerning
τὸ27
tò
the
θανάτου28
thanátou
death
,
διότι29
dióti
thatbecause
δεινόν30
deinón
it is terriblefearful, (also) clever
,
ἐκεῖνο31
ekei͂no
thatthat one
τοῦ32
tou͂
the
ἐστιν33
estin
isto be, to exist
 
the
δεινόν34
deinón
terrible thingfearful, (also) clever
.
ὅταν35
hótan
Wheneverwhen
οὖν36
ou͂n
thentherefore, so
ἐμποδιζώμεθα37
empodizṓmetha
we are hinderedto hinder, impede
ἢ38
ḕ
orthan
ταρασσώμεθα39
tarassṓmetha
disturbedto stir up, trouble, disturb
ἢ40
ḕ
orthan
λυπώμεθα41
lupṓmetha
grievedto pain, grieve, (pass.) be distressed
,
μηδέποτε42
mēdépote
never
αἰτιώμεθα43
aitiṓmetha
let us blameto blame, hold responsible, accuse
ἄλλον44
állon
anotherother
,
ἀλλʼ45
allʼ
butyet
ἑαυτούς46
heautoús
ourselvesof himself / themselves
τοῦτʼ47
tou͂tʼ
thatthis, this one
ἔστι48
ésti
isto be, to exist
,
τὸ49
tò
the
ἑαυτῶν50
heautō͂n
our ownof himself / themselves
δόγματα51
dógmata
opinionsopinion, judgment, belief
.
 
It is the
ἔργον52
érgon
markwork, deed, doing
 
of
ἀπαιδεύτου53
apaideútou
the uneducateduntrained
τὰ54
tà
the
ἄλλοις55
állois
othersother, another
ἐγκαλεῖν56
enkalei͂n
to accuseto bring a charge against
ἐφʼ57
ephʼ
foron, upon, (with dative) in the power of
οἷς58
ohi͂s
whatwho, which, that
αὐτὸς59
autòs
he himselfself, him / her / it, the same
πράσσει60
prássei
doesto do, act, fare
κακῶς61
kakō͂s
badlyill
;
 
the mark of
ἠργμένου62
ērgménou
one who has begunto begin, to rule
παιδεύεσθαι63
paideúesthai
to be taughtto educate, train, discipline
,
 
to accuse
τὸ64
tò
the
ἑαυτῷ65
heautō͂i
himselfof himself / themselves
;
 
the mark of one
πεπαιδευμένου66
pepaideuménou
fully taughtto educate, train, discipline
τὸ67
tò
the
,
 
to blame
τὸ68
tò
the
μήτε69
mḗte
neitherand not, (μήτε … μήτε) neither … nor
ἄλλῳ70
állōi
anotherother
μήτε71
mḗte
norand not, (μήτε … μήτε) neither … nor
ἑαυτῷ72
heautō͂i
himselfof himself / themselves
.
It is not the things that disturb people, but the opinions about things. Death, for example, is nothing terrible — since to Socrates too it would have seemed so — but the opinion about death, that it is terrible, that is the terrible thing. So whenever we are hindered or disturbed or grieved, let us never blame anyone else, but ourselves — that is, our own opinions. It is the mark of the uneducated to accuse others for what he himself does badly; the mark of one beginning to be taught, to accuse himself; the mark of one fully taught, to blame neither anyone else nor himself.

It is not the things that disturb people, but the opinions about things. Death, for example, is nothing terrible — since to Socrates too it would have seemed so — but the opinion about death, that it is terrible, that is the terrible thing. So whenever we are hindered or disturbed or grieved, let us never blame anyone else, but ourselves — that is, our own opinions. It is the mark of the uneducated to accuse others for what he himself does badly; the mark of one beginning to be taught, to accuse himself; the mark of one fully taught, to blame neither anyone else nor himself.
Interpretation
It is not things that disturb people, but their opinions about things. Death, for example, is nothing terrible — or it would have seemed so to Socrates too — but the opinion about death, that it is terrible, that is the terrible thing. So whenever we are hindered or disturbed or grieved, let us never blame anyone else, but ourselves — that is, our own opinions. To accuse others for what one does badly oneself is the mark of a person with no education; to accuse oneself, of one who has begun to learn; to blame neither anyone else nor oneself, of one whose education is complete.
This is the hinge the whole Stoic therapy turns on. Between an event and your distress sits a judgment (δόγμα), and Epictetus's claim is that the distress lives in the judgment, not the event. Death is his deliberately extreme case: if death itself were terrible, it would terrify everyone equally, Socrates included — but it did not terrify Socrates, so the terror must come from what people decide about death, not from death. Change the verdict and the feeling changes with it. Two thousand years later this is the premise of cognitive behavioral therapy, which quotes this very line. The second half turns the knife on the reader. Epictetus grades you by whom you blame: point at others and you have not begun; point at yourself and you have started; blame no one at all — because you have stopped issuing the verdicts that produce blame — and the work is done. It is not a counsel of self-reproach but of ownership: the only judgments you can revise are your own, so they are the only place the cure can be applied.
8.1
Enchiridion 8.1 · Wish things as they are
Four lines that hold the heart of the discipline of desire. Do not bend events to your will; bend your will to events — and the result is a life that flows.
· · ·

Do not seek the things that happen to happen as you wish, but wish the things that happen to happen as they do, and you will go on well.
↓ Keep reading in the book