‹ LibraryEnchiridion · Chapter 1Read on ›
1.2
Enchiridion 1.2 · Free by nature, or another's
Having drawn the line, Epictetus states the character of each side. What is up to us is free by its very nature; what is not is weak and belongs to others — a fact about the world, not a preference.
· · ·
καὶ1
kaì
Andalso, even
τὰ2
tà
the things
μὲν3
mèn
indeedon the one hand
ἐφʼ4
ephʼ
up toon, upon, (with dative) in the power of
ἡμῖν5
hēmi͂n
uswe, (dative) us
ἐστι6
esti
areto be, to exist
φύσει7
phúsei
by naturenatural constitution
ἐλεύθερα8
eleúthera
freeunconstrained
,
ἀκώλυτα9
akṓluta
unhinderedunimpeded
,
ἀπαραπόδιστα10
aparapódista
unobstructedunimpeded
;
δὲ11
dè
butand
τὰ12
tà
the others
,
 
the ones
οὐκ13
ouk
not
ἐφʼ14
ephʼ
up toon, upon, (with dative) in the power of
ἡμῖν15
hēmi͂n
uswe, (dative) us
,
 
are
ἀσθενῆ16
asthenē͂
weakfeeble, without strength
,
δοῦλα17
dou͂la
slavishenslaved, servile, (noun) a slave
,
κωλυτά18
kōlutá
hinderableable to be hindered, preventable
,
ἀλλότρια19
allótria
another'sbelonging to someone else, alien
.
And the things up to us are by nature free, unhindered, unobstructed; but the others, the ones not up to us, are weak, slavish, able to be hindered, and another's.

And the things up to us are by nature free, unhindered, unobstructed; but the others, the ones not up to us, are weak, slavish, able to be hindered, and another's.
Interpretation
And the things up to us are by nature free, unhindered, unobstructed; but the things not up to us are weak, slavish, hinderable, and belong to others.
The two lists are not just differently labeled; they are differently built. Whatever is truly up to you — your judgments, your choices — is free by nature, which means nothing outside can finally block it. Whatever is not up to you is the opposite: weak, dependent, able to be stopped, and ultimately somebody else's. Epictetus is not moralizing here but describing a structure he thinks is simply the case. The word doing the quiet work is ἀλλότριος, "another's." To treat what is another's as your own is, on this view, the standing mistake — it hands your peace to things that were never under your command. The promise hidden in the bleak-sounding words is real: if the free part is the only part that is yours, then the one thing you cannot be robbed of is exactly the thing that matters most.
1.3
Enchiridion 1.3 · Then no one can harm you
The payoff of the dichotomy, stated as a chain of consequences. Confuse the two lists and you are at everyone's mercy; keep them straight and nothing outside you can touch you — the most sweeping promise in the Handbook.
· · ·

Remember, then, that if you suppose the things slavish by nature to be free, and what is another's your own, you will be hindered, you will grieve, you will be disturbed, you will blame both gods and men. But if you suppose only what is yours to be yours, and what is another's another's — as it is, no one will ever compel you, ever, no one will hinder you, you will blame no one, you will accuse no one, unwillingly you will do not one thing, no one will harm you, you will have no enemy, for you will suffer nothing harmful.
↓ Keep reading in the book