1.4
Enchiridion 1.4 · You cannot have it both ways
A sober qualification. The freedom just promised is not a part-time pursuit; it asks you to let some things go completely. Chase it alongside office and wealth, Epictetus warns, and you will likely lose both — the freedom for certain.
· · ·
ἐφιέμενος1
ephiémenos
Aiming atto send to, (mid. + gen.) to aim at, long for
οὖν2
ou͂n
thentherefore, so
, τηλικούτων3
tēlikoútōn
such great thingsso great, so important, of such a size
, μέμνησο4
mémnēso
rememberto remind, (mid. / perf. μέμνησο) remember
ὅτι5
hóti
thatbecause
οὐ6
ou
not
δεῖ7
dei͂
you mustit is necessary, one must
ἅπτεσθαι8
háptesthai
take holdto fasten, (mid. + gen.) to take hold of, grasp
αὐτῶν9
autō͂n
of themself, him / her / it, the same
only
μετρίως10
metríōs
moderatelymoderate, measured, (adv.) half-heartedly
κεκινημένον11
kekinēménon
movedto move, set in motion, stir
, ἀλλὰ12
allà
butyet
τὰ13
tà
somethe
ἀφιέναι14
aphiénai
let goto send away, release, give up
μὲν15
mèn
indeedon the one hand
παντελῶς16
pantelō͂s
entirelycomplete, entire, (adv. παντελῶς) entirely
, τὰ17
tà
othersthe
δʼ18
dʼ
andbut
ὑπερτίθεσθαι19
hupertíthesthai
postponeto put off, defer
πρὸς20
pròs
forto, toward, (+ acc.) in relation to
τὸ21
tò
the
παρόν22
parón
presentto be present, (τὸ παρόν) the present
. ἐὰν23
eàn
If
δὲ24
dè
butand
καὶ25
kaì
alsoand, even
ταῦτʼ26
tau͂tʼ
thesethis, this one
ἐθέλῃς27
ethélēis
you wantto wish, be willing
καὶ28
kaì
bothand, also, even
ἄρχειν29
árkhein
to hold officeto begin, to rule
καὶ30
kaì
andalso, even
πλουτεῖν31
ploutei͂n
to be richto be wealthy
, τυχὸν32
tukhòn
perhapsto hit upon, obtain (+ gen.), to happen
μὲν33
mèn
indeedon the one hand
οὐδʼ34
oudʼ
not evenand not, nor
αὐτῶν35
autō͂n
themselvesself, him / her / it, the same
τούτων36
toútōn
of thesethis, this one
τεύξῃ37
teúxēi
you will getto hit upon, obtain (+ gen.), to happen, (τυχόν) perhaps
, διὰ38
dià
because ofthrough (+ gen.)
τὸ39
tò
the
ἐφίεσθαι40
ephíesthai
reaching forto send to, (mid. + gen.) to aim at, long for
καὶ41
kaì
alsoand, even
τῶν42
tō͂n
the
προτέρων43
protérōn
former thingsearlier, the first-mentioned
; πάντως44
pántōs
altogetherall, every, whole, (adv. πάντως) altogether, at all
γε45
ge
at leastindeed
μὴν46
mḕn
at any ratetruly, surely
ἐκείνων47
ekeínōn
thosethat, that one
ἀποτεύξη48
apoteúxē
you will fail to getto miss
, διʼ49
diʼ
throughthrough (+ gen.), because of
ὧν50
hō͂n
whichwho, that
μόνων51
mónōn
aloneonly, sole
ἐλευθερία52
eleuthería
freedomliberty
καὶ53
kaì
andalso, even
εὐδαιμονία54
eudaimonía
happinessflourishing, well-being
περιγίνεται55
perigínetai
come aboutto result, to prevail, survive
. Aiming, then, at such great things, remember that you must not take hold of them half-moved, but let some go entirely, and postpone others for the present. But if you also want these and both to hold office and to be rich, perhaps you will not get even these you will get, because you were reaching for the former too; but at any rate you will fail to get those, through which alone freedom and happiness come about.
Aiming, then, at such great things, remember that you must not take hold of them half-moved, but let some go entirely, and postpone others for the present. But if you also want these and both to hold office and to be rich, perhaps you will not get even these you will get, because you were reaching for the former too; but at any rate you will fail to get those, through which alone freedom and happiness come about.
Interpretation
Aiming, then, at such great things, remember that you must not take hold of them half-heartedly, but must let some things go entirely and postpone others for the present. But if you want these and also to hold office and to be rich, you may perhaps not get even the latter, just because you were reaching for the former too; and at any rate you will fail to get the things through which alone freedom and happiness come about.
After the soaring promises of 1.3, this is the cold print of the contract. Epictetus has just offered a freedom nothing can touch, and here he names its price: you cannot reach for it "half-moved." Some things have to be released completely, others shelved for now. The Stoic goal is not one more good item to add to an already full life; it asks you to change what you are reaching for.
The warning is sharpened into a wager. Try to have both the inner freedom and the outward goods — office, wealth — and the likeliest outcome is that you get neither the freedom (for certain) nor even, perhaps, the externals, because a divided reach is a weak one. The phrase "through which alone" (δι' ὧν μόνων) is the knife: freedom and happiness have exactly one road, and it is not the road that also runs through the magistrate's chair and the counting-house. It is less a prohibition than a piece of hard arithmetic about where a single life's attention can go.
1.5
Enchiridion 1.5 · You are only an impression
The chapter closes with the one practice that makes the rest workable. The moment a harsh impression hits — fear, craving, a surge of anger — you learn to stop and speak to it, stripping it of the authority it claims, then test it against the single question: is this up to me, or not?
· · ·
At once, then, to every harsh impression practice saying: you are an impression and not at all the thing you appear. Then examine it and test it by these rules that you have, and first, above all, above all, whether it concerns the things up to us or the things not up to us. not up to us; and if it concerns one of the things not up to us, be ready with this: that it is nothing to me.